The Visibility Gap: Why Customers Tolerate Delay but Not Confusion
Getting a car back quickly matters after an accident. Yet Laird Assessors Director Nik Ellis argues that speed tells only part of the story. Customers also need to understand where their claim stands, especially when repairs are delayed.
Picture a car in a bodyshop, six weeks into a wait for a back-ordered part.
The repair can’t start without it. The hire bill keeps running. And the policyholder is on the phone, trying to find out what’s going on.
The insurer says one thing. The bodyshop says another. The hire company isn’t sure.
For Nik, the delay itself is only part of the problem. How effectively it is managed and communicated can be equally important.
“Customers can tolerate delays far better than they can tolerate confusion,” he writes in issue 78 of Modern Insurance Magazine.
A claim taking longer than expected isn’t necessarily what frustrates people most, he argues. It’s not knowing what’s happening, who’s responsible or when anything will move.
Nik has spent many years across the claims and bodyshop sectors, and he knows the case for speed well. In a 2023 column, he credited automation with getting hire cars “authorised without delay, reducing key-to-key times”.
Getting the vehicle back quickly still matters. But, as he puts it, it is “only part of the equation.” Efficient processes and clear communication must work together, particularly when a repair stops going to plan.
Why Claims Processes Must Be Designed for the Unexpected
The industry, in Nik’s view, has become very good at managing the predictable journey: the straightforward claim, “green lights all the way”.
The trouble starts when something breaks the pattern. A part goes on back order. The ADAS needs extra diagnostic work. Strip-down uncovers more damage. Each one stretches key-to-key time, and the hire with it.
Those are the moments “where trust is either strengthened or lost,” he writes.
His view is that “the most important claims aren’t the ones progressing exactly as expected, but the ones that aren’t.”
The lesson for anyone designing a claims process is to build for the exceptions from day one, instead of treating them as edge cases.
Six Weeks Is Still Six Weeks
None of this gets a part to the bodyshop any sooner. As Nik puts it, “a vehicle waiting six weeks for a part is still waiting six weeks for a part.”
What changes is how those six weeks are experienced. Spent “chasing updates, receiving conflicting information and wondering if anyone is paying attention”, they wear away trust. Spent knowing where things stand, why, and what is being done about it, they become a delay the customer can at least understand, even if the inconvenience and associated costs remain.
The conflicting answers are the part claims teams can fix. A motor claim’s status sits with the insurer, the assessor, the repairer, the hire provider and often a broker. When each holds a different version, the customer’s answer depends on who picks up the phone.
Nik wants all of them, policyholder included, “working from the same version of the truth.”
An explanation isn’t a fix, of course. Better coordination and faster decisions should still clear avoidable hold-ups. But visibility lets everyone tell a genuine constraint, such as an unavailable part, from a claim that has simply stopped moving.
Modern technology has an important role here, identifying exceptions earlier, sharing consistent information and reducing the administrative work involved in keeping everyone informed.
The rules already point this way. ICOBS 8.1.1R requires insurers to provide “appropriate information on its progress” when handling a claim, and that duty doesn’t pause while a part is on back order.
Counting the Wrong Things
Then there is the question of what claims teams measure.
“For too long, our industry has measured activity rather than outcomes,” Nik writes. Teams count notifications, calls and milestones, yet often can’t see a claim “drifting off course until a complaint arrives.”
Most claims leaders will recognise that from their own MI packs. Volumes and service levels show how busy a team is. They say much less about whether a customer understands the state of their repair.
The more revealing questions are simple ones. Does the policyholder understand the reason for a delay and what happens next? Are the insurer, assessor and repairer giving the same account? When a claim goes off plan, how quickly is it identified, assigned an owner and explained?
Speed and service levels still belong in the pack. They just need to sit alongside evidence that customers have a reliable picture of their claim, and that emerging problems are dealt with before they become complaints.
The regulator expects no less. Since July 2023, the Consumer Duty has required firms to “regularly monitor the outcomes retail customers receive”, including from their communications and customer support (PRIN 2A.9.8R). Firms must also find the root causes when those outcomes fall short (PRIN 2A.9.11R).
And the complaints are already arriving. Between April and June 2026, the Financial Ombudsman Service received 4,100 car and motorcycle insurance complaints, up from 2,800 a year earlier. Claim delays were among several concerns consumers raised, alongside issues such as claim values and policy cancellations.
The warning signs show up long before the ombudsman does, for any team measuring the right things.
The Clearest View of Reality
Where does that leave the industry? Nik has a prediction: “The next generation of claims management will be defined by who can provide the clearest view of reality.”
Customers, he adds, don’t expect perfection. “What they expect is honesty, visibility and confidence that somebody has a firm grip on their claim from start to finish.”
It’s a simple test for any claims operation: could everyone working on a claim tell the customer the same thing today?
Never miss an issue. Modern Insurance Magazine is published bi-monthly in print, and subscriptions are free. Sign up for your free copy on our magazine page, where you can also read issue 78 and back issues online.
Further reading
Fellow board member Eddie Longworth makes a related case in his Editors’ Pick, Claims Don’t Fail on Decisions. They Fail on Explanations.
Read Nik Ellis’s full column, The Visibility Gap: Why Transparency Matters More Than Speed in Claims, on page 23 of issue 78. The issue looks at the gap between what customers expect from a claim and what the industry delivers, and also features AXA’s Martin Milliner on The Next Chapter for Claims.
Nik Ellis is a Director at Laird Assessors and a member of the Modern Insurance Magazine Editorial Board.